Individuality
·
Self-Awareness
AI Can Personalize the Lesson. Only an Adult Can Personalize the Starting Point.
A high school math teacher writes in The Hechinger Report that personalized learning too often starts with a student's labels and gaps, and AI could make that habit permanent. When teachers start with what students care about, the standard stays high and the reason to learn finally arrives.
What the Headlines Miss · Responding to
TEACHER VOICE: The future of personalized learning cannot be built on technology alone
Al Rabanera teaches algebra at La Vista High School in Fullerton, California. In The future of personalized learning cannot be built on technology alone, a Teacher Voice essay for The Hechinger Report, he describes students who walk into his classroom already knowing what their school thinks they are bad at. They carry labels like remedial and low-performing before they open a notebook. Too often, he argues, personalized learning starts right there, with a low score or a missing skill, and builds everything around fixing it.
His worry is that AI will make that habit faster and more permanent. The technology can generate practice problems, adjust reading levels and give instant feedback, but it can only personalize the information we give it. Feed it gaps, and it will sort students by what they cannot do yet.
The Data Can't Tell You Who Is in the Seat
Rabanera's alternative starts with a question most of us have heard from a teenager. A student he calls Kyle asked why he had to learn math his phone could solve in seconds. Rabanera skipped the usual answers about tests and credits. He asked Kyle what he cared about. Cars, music and making money turned into car loans, monthly payments and the long-term cost of financial choices, and AI helped him build the practice around them. Kyle's confidence shifted because the math was finally connected to his own future.
The essay is framed as advice about AI in the classroom. I read it as a story about who gets to define a student. For generations, school has defined the young person: the placement, the track, the label. Rabanera flips the order. He lets what Kyle cares about shape how the lesson is built, and the lesson gets stronger because of it. In his words, "interest is not a distraction from rigor." It is often the way in.
That is the difference between customizing content and personalizing learning. A platform can customize a worksheet. Only someone who knows the student can choose where the worksheet should begin.
The national picture shows how much room there is to grow. In the latest Walton Family Foundation and Gallup Voices of Gen Z survey of 1,758 students ages 14 to 19, just 51% agree that school gives them the opportunity to do what they do best. And 70% agree an adult at school recognizes their individual talents and interests, which means about three in ten do not. Gallup also found that students with the most engaging school experiences are about three times as likely to feel prepared for the future as the least engaged.
Standards Give the Lesson Its Shape. The Student Gives It a Reason.
Rabanera is careful on one point, and it matters. Starting with Kyle's interests did not lower the bar. A math teacher still has to know where a student is struggling, and shared standards are what make sure every student reaches real proficiency. That consistency is an asset. It is what lets a parent trust that algebra in one classroom means the same thing in the next.
The trouble starts when the standard becomes the whole story about the student. A young person who struggles with equations may be a sharp thinker when the problem is about a family business, a paycheck or a sport. When school only measures the gap, that young person learns to see themselves as the gap. Many spend years editing who they are to fit the label, and some carry it into adulthood.
AI can help a teacher move faster. It cannot supply the reason to learn. That came from a conversation, and from an adult curious enough to ask. I made a related point in One-to-One Was Supposed to Mean a Laptop. It Should Mean an Adult. The device was never the personal part.
Where to Start This Week
For teachers: before the next unit, ask each student one question about something they care about outside school. Then use AI to build one problem around their answer.
For parents: when your teen says a subject is pointless, ask what they would rather be solving. The answer is often a better doorway into the subject than another lecture about grades.
For school leaders: look at what information your AI tools are given about students. If it is only scores and gaps, you are personalizing the deficit.
For students: notice which problems you would work on even if no one graded them. That is information about who you are, and it is worth telling a teacher. I explored this in Students Don't Need a Major First. They Need to Know What They Enjoy Solving.
Rabanera ends where every good teacher begins: with what students care about, what they are trying to become and what already makes sense to them. AI can carry that work further than ever before. But someone has to ask the first question.
Personalization doesn't begin with what a student is missing. It begins with knowing what they care about.
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
Personalization doesn't begin with what a student is missing. It begins with knowing what they care about.
© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
This article is the original work of Glenn Llopis and is protected by copyright. It may not be republished, reproduced, distributed or adapted, in whole or in part, in print, online or by AI tools, without prior written consent. You are welcome to share the link or quote a brief excerpt with credit to Glenn Llopis and a link back to this page. For permission requests, contact solutions@glennllopisgroup.com.
Get the next essay in your inbox
New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.
Something went wrong. Please try again.


