Individuality
·
Trust
Good Intentions Aren't Enough for School Wellbeing Programs
School wellbeing programs are built with care, and many help. But an Oxford-linked review of 112 programs found that most studies never set out to look for harm, and some reported it. Here is what parents can calmly ask so every student is served, not just the average one.

Somewhere this fall, your teenager probably sat in a circle, or a classroom, or an assembly, and was walked through a program designed to support their mental health. Breathing exercises. A unit on managing stress. A mindfulness session before first period.
The people who build and run these programs care about kids. I want to say that clearly at the start, because what follows is not an argument against them. It is an argument for asking a question that schools, researchers and parents have been slow to ask: is this helping every student in the room, or only the students it was designed around?
What 112 Programs Revealed When Researchers Looked for Harm
Lucy Foulkes is a psychologist at the University of Oxford who studies adolescent mental health, and the author of a book on adolescence, Coming of Age. She and her colleagues have been pressing a point that sounds obvious once you hear it: if a program can help, it can also, for some young people, do the opposite. And unless we measure that, we won't know.
In a 2025 scoping review led by Guzman-Holst, with Foulkes as senior author, the team searched eight research databases for controlled trials of school-based group mental health programs built on cognitive behavioral or mindfulness approaches. They found 112 programs described in 120 studies. Ten of those 112 programs, or 8.93 percent, reported at least one negative outcome, such as a drop in wellbeing or a rise in anxiety for some participants. Among the 15 studies the team rated as high quality, 5 reported at least one negative outcome. Three programs reported specific adverse events, and none of those events was linked to the program itself.
Two things stood out to me. First, about half of the studies that reported a negative outcome, 54.5 percent, acknowledged that the content of the program might have played a role. Second, the review notes that negative outcomes showed up in particular groups, including higher-risk students, boys, younger children and children eligible for free school meals.
The authors are careful about what this means, and so should we be. The review counts what studies reported. It does not tell us how often programs cause harm, and most of the studies were never designed to look for harm in the first place. That is exactly the point. If nobody is looking, the absence of bad news is not good news.
Why One Program for Everyone Can Miss Someone
In a 2024 paper in Nature Mental Health, Foulkes and colleagues, including Jack Andrews, wrote that there is "growing evidence that universal school-based mental health interventions can lead to negative outcomes." Using simulated data, they showed how a small negative effect, spread across a whole population of students, could add up to considerable harm. They called for researchers to plan for and measure potential harm from the start.
That is a principle I recognize from decades of work with organizations. A program built for the average person can be a wonderful thing. Structure gives everyone a shared starting point, and schools need structure. But no room full of people is average. The same session that settles one student can stir something up in another. One teen finds a breathing exercise calming. Another, asked to turn inward in front of classmates, feels exposed. Same room, same script, two different experiences.
I made a similar case about screens in Social Media Isn't Good or Bad for Your Teen. It's Personal. The same is true here. A wellbeing program isn't simply good or bad. Its effect depends on who is sitting in the chair.
Calm Questions Worth Asking Your Child's School
None of this calls for alarm, and none of it means opting your child out of everything. Most parents will never need to do more than stay curious. Here is what that curiosity can look like.
Ask what the program is and what it is meant to do. A school that has chosen a program thoughtfully will be glad to tell you.
Ask how the school will know whether it is working, and for whom. "Do you check in with students afterward?" is a fair, friendly question.
Ask whether a student can step back from an activity without being singled out. Choice is one of the simplest protections a program can build in.
Then ask your own teen, without leading them. "What was that session like for you?" leaves room for an honest answer. If they say it helped, wonderful. If they say it made them feel worse, or more on display, believe them and pass it along.
For educators, the same respect applies. As I wrote in Students and Educators Need Permission to Be Individuals, the people closest to students often see first who a lesson is reaching and who it is missing. Their observations are data too.
Caring Enough to Check
I come back to the question at the center of my work with teens and parents: are we seeing the individual, or only the group? A wellbeing program is an act of care. Measuring whether it is working for each young person is the next act of care, and in many ways the more important one.
Good intentions start the work. Paying attention to the student the average misses is how we finish it.
Research cited
Guzman-Holst, C., Streckfuss Davis, R., Andrews, J. L., et al. (2025). Scoping review: Potential harm from school-based group mental health interventions. Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Foulkes, L., Andrews, J. L., Reardon, T., et al. (2024). Research recommendations for assessing potential harm from universal school-based mental health interventions. Nature Mental Health.
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
Caring for young people means being willing to ask whether our help is working for each of them, not just whether it was well meant.
© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
This article is the original work of Glenn Llopis and is protected by copyright. It may not be republished, reproduced, distributed or adapted, in whole or in part, in print, online or by AI tools, without prior written consent. You are welcome to share the link or quote a brief excerpt with credit to Glenn Llopis and a link back to this page. For permission requests, contact solutions@glennllopisgroup.com.
Get the next essay in your inbox
New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.
Something went wrong. Please try again.



