Individuality

·

Individuality

Belonging Programs May Be Built for the Outgoing Kid

A study of 4,753 first-year college students found that outgoing, agreeable students tended to report more belonging, and anxious ones less. Belonging early in college also went with finishing. Here is how parents can prepare the teen they actually have, not the one the welcome week imagines.

By Glenn Llopis

·

5

min read

Belonging Programs May Be Built for the Outgoing Kid, an article by Glenn Llopis

Picture the first week of college. The welcome barbecue, the floor meeting, the club fair with rows of folding tables, the icebreaker where everyone shares a fun fact about themselves. Now picture the student who would rather have one long conversation than forty short ones. Was that week built for her?

I have been turning that question over since reading a study from a team that includes Wake Forest University psychologist Shannon Brady. Parents of high schoolers should hear about it now, while the move to college is still a few years off and there is time to prepare the kid you actually have, not the one the brochure imagines.

Who Felt at Home by the End of Freshman Year

The study, led by Alexandria Stubblebine with Maithreyi Gopalan of Penn State and Brady as senior author, drew on 4,753 first-year students at 12 four-year colleges and universities in the United States and Canada. The researchers measured students' personalities and then asked how much they felt they belonged at the end of their first year.

Students who scored higher on extraversion and agreeableness tended to report more belonging. Students who scored higher on neuroticism, the tendency toward worry and negative emotion, tended to report less. Openness to new experiences showed no link at all. There was also an exploratory hint that being outgoing helped more at large schools, but it showed up at only one of the two points when personality was measured, so I treat it as a question rather than an answer.

Some honest cautions. The data came from a larger randomized trial of a belonging program, but this paper is a secondary analysis, and its personality findings are correlational. The links were small, and the personality measure was brief. Nobody should read this and conclude that a quiet kid is destined to feel like an outsider. What it shows is a tilt: on average, belonging came a little easier to students whose temperament matched the way campus life tends to run.

The authors drew a practical lesson from it, and it is the line I would hand to every dean of students. As Stubblebine, Gopalan and Brady wrote in PLOS One, "We encourage institutions to create multiple, varied pathways to belonging," and to be clear that belonging takes time.

Why That Tilt Matters Long After Orientation

You might think feeling at home freshman year is pleasant but not decisive. A second paper, by Brady and Gopalan in Educational Researcher, suggests it may be worth more than we assume. Using a nationally representative sample of 21,700 U.S. undergraduates who started college in the 2011 to 2012 school year, they found that each one-point increase in first-year belonging, on a five-point scale, went with a 3.4 percentage-point higher rate of earning a credential within four years, and 2.7 points within six.

That is an association, not proof. Belonging was measured with a single survey question, and students who felt at home may have differed in plenty of other ways. But set the two papers side by side and a pattern worth a parent's attention appears. Belonging in the first year travels with finishing, and belonging does not arrive evenly. If the main doorways into campus life are loud and social, some students will walk right through, and others will stand outside wondering what is wrong with them.

Nothing is wrong with them. They are being offered one kind of room.

Belonging Shouldn't Require a Different Temperament

This is where the research ends and my own view begins. I have spent much of my career watching capable adults edit themselves to fit what a workplace rewards: louder in meetings, quicker with small talk, more polished than they feel inside. I suspect many of them picked up that habit long before their first job, in a dorm lounge at 18, deciding that the way to belong was to act more outgoing than they were.

That kind of adjustment is fitting in, and it is different from belonging. I wrote about the difference in Belonging Isn't Fitting In. The Research Can Tell the Difference., and this study adds a wrinkle I hadn't fully considered. Sometimes the pressure to fit in comes less from peers than from the design of the welcome itself.

Structure is valuable. Orientation programs, residence life and first-year seminars exist for good reasons, and many of them help. The trouble starts with a one-size room, built around one temperament and presented as the way everyone finds their place. For a quieter student, belonging may come through a research lab, a small studio class, a campus job, a faith community, a running group or one roommate who becomes a lifelong friend. Those are not second-best routes. They are routes that fit who the student is.

Preparing the Teen You Actually Have

If your teen is heading toward college in the next few years, a few things are worth doing now.

Talk about belonging before it becomes a crisis. Tell them plainly that feeling out of place in the first months is common, and that it is not proof they chose the wrong school.

Help them notice how they connect best. Ask, "Where have you felt most like yourself with other people?" The answer might be a team, a band, a part-time job or a single good friend. That is the pattern to look for on campus.

Look past welcome week when you visit schools. Ask what small-group options exist, how students get involved in research or campus jobs, and whether there are ways to connect that don't start with a crowd.

Encourage stretching, but not shape-shifting. Trying the club fair is healthy. Pretending to be a different person to survive it is not. The goal is for your teen to find their people, not to perform a temperament they don't have.

And if your teen is the outgoing one, that is a gift too. Ask them to watch for the student at the edge of the room. Belonging spreads faster when the people who find it easily make space for those who don't.

Families spend a lot of energy on where a teen should go, which is why I wrote Before Choosing College or the Trades, Ask Who You're Becoming. This research adds a companion question for once they arrive: will there be a door that fits them?

A young person should never have to become louder to be welcomed. The places worth choosing are the ones with more than one way in.

Research cited

Stubblebine, A. M., Gopalan, M., & Brady, S. T. (2024). Who feels like they belong? Personality and belonging in college. PLOS One.

Brady, S. T., & Gopalan, M. (2025). College students' sense of belonging: A graduation update. Educational Researcher.

Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.

Conviction Wisdom

A young person should never have to become louder to be welcomed; the places worth choosing are the ones with more than one way in.

Glenn Llopis

Founder and CEO of Glenn Llopis Group, author of six books and creator of Leadership in the Age of Personalization.

Take the Conviction Diagnostic
SUBSCRIBE

Get the next essay in your inbox

New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.

Something went wrong. Please try again.

The Conviction Diagnostic
How much of you is edited?

Take the Conviction Diagnostic. In three minutes, see where you've traded who you are for who the room wanted, and exactly where to begin reclaiming it.

Start with the question most leaders can’t answer in a sentence: What do you solve for?
Begin the Conviction Diagnostic

© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC · All Rights Reserved

Identity Catalyst · ˈyō-pēs