Individuality
·
Leadership
AI Can Coach a Manager. It Can't Develop One.
AI coaching tools are arriving on managers' desktops before many managers were ever developed. A tool can supply the words for a hard conversation. Only development before the vacancy builds the judgment to use them well.

A new kind of help is arriving on managers' desktops. AI coaching tools now draft feedback, suggest how to open a hard conversation and flag which team member might be drifting. For a manager who has never had a real development plan, that can feel like a lifeline.
It is also a warning sign. In many organizations, the tool is arriving before the development ever did.
The gap the tools are filling
The numbers describe a role that has been asked to carry more while receiving less. Gallup's State of the Global Workplace 2026 found that manager engagement fell from 27% to 22% in a single year, the steepest drop it has recorded for the group. The year before, Gallup reported that fewer than half of the world's managers said they had received any management training at all.
Meanwhile, managers are already reaching for AI on their own. In The Predictive Index's 2026 AI and People Leadership Survey, 72% of managers said they use public AI tools to prepare for sensitive employee conversations. Forty-two percent said they know what to say before a difficult conversation but struggle with how to say it.
That last finding is the heart of the matter. A tool can supply the words. It can't supply the judgment, the relationship or the courage that make the words land.
Development happens before the vacancy
Most organizations still develop managers in response to an opening. Someone leaves, a strong individual contributor is promoted, and the training starts after the title changes. By then, the new manager is learning to lead in front of the very people they're supposed to be leading.
The work that matters most happens years earlier, in small moments few people notice. It's the first time a high performer is asked to help a struggling teammate. The first time they disagree with their own manager and see what happens. The first time they own a problem nobody assigned to them. Those moments reveal who someone is becoming as a leader long before any program does.
When I work with organizations on their leadership pipelines, I ask one question first: who on your teams is already leading without the title, and what are you doing to see them? The answer is usually silence. Not because those people don't exist, but because no one has been asked to look.
The cost of skipping this step shows up later. A manager promoted without preparation tends to fall back on what made them successful as an individual: doing the work themselves, solving every problem personally, measuring their value by their own output. Their team feels it as micromanagement. The manager feels it as exhaustion. And the organization calls it a performance issue when it was really a development gap it chose not to close.
Developing managers before the vacancy also does something less obvious. It tells the people around them what the organization values. When employees see that leadership potential is noticed and nurtured early, they start showing more of it.
Where AI helps, and where it can't
I'm not against these tools. Used well, they can help a manager prepare, reflect and practice. A manager who rehearses a conversation with an AI coach before having it may handle it better than one who walks in cold.
But AI coaching tends to work best for managers who already know who they are. A manager with a clear sense of their own values uses the tool to sharpen their delivery. A manager who never developed that sense uses it to borrow one. The first becomes more themselves. The second becomes more generic, and the people they lead can feel it.
That's the risk of layering technology on top of an undeveloped role. It can make a manager look ready without making them ready.
What leaders can do now
Find your future managers before you need them. Ask team leads to name the people already doing leadership work informally. Give those people stretch assignments, honest feedback and a sponsor.
Develop judgment, not just skills. Skills can be taught in a module. Judgment is built through real decisions and conversations about what happened afterward. Make room for both.
Set guidelines for how managers use AI. The same Predictive Index survey found that 44% of managers admit putting real employee names or performance data into public AI tools. Clear guidance protects both the employee and the manager.
Pair every tool with a person. An AI coach is most valuable when a human mentor helps the manager make sense of what it suggests.
As I've written about what happens after the training ends, the real test of a manager isn't what they know. It's what they do on an ordinary day when no one is checking. No tool can take that test for them.
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
A tool can make a manager sound ready. Only development makes them ready.
© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
This article is the original work of Glenn Llopis and is protected by copyright. It may not be republished, reproduced, distributed or adapted, in whole or in part, in print, online or by AI tools, without prior written consent. You are welcome to share the link or quote a brief excerpt with credit to Glenn Llopis and a link back to this page. For permission requests, contact solutions@glennllopisgroup.com.
Get the next essay in your inbox
New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.
Something went wrong. Please try again.


