Opportunity
·
Leadership
Succession Isn't a Search. It's Years of Seeing People in Different Rooms.
The Wall Street Journal shares how Target rotated internal candidates through roles so its board could watch them lead, then gave the new CEO the room to himself. With most new CEOs now chosen from inside, the real question is how well a board actually knows its people.
What the Headlines Miss · Responding to
How Target Planned for Brian Cornell's Successor
As questions swirl about succession at Nvidia, The Wall Street Journal's CEO Brief offers a useful contrast. In How Target Planned for Brian Cornell's Successor, Erle Norton recounts a conversation with Target's executive chair at the WSJ Board of Directors Council Summit. Cornell explained that when he reached the retailer's retirement age, the board kept him in place to finish developing the next generation of leaders. Working with his HR partner, he rotated several internal candidates through different roles so the board could watch them lead across the enterprise. Michael Fiddelke, who became CEO this year, held five or six roles along the way. The board considered outsiders too, and the plan covered the C-suite that would surround the new chief.
Then came the detail I keep thinking about. Days after Fiddelke was named, Cornell told him, "There can only be one CEO in the room at the same time." He packed up his office and moved to the other side of the building, five months before the official handoff.
A Résumé Shows What Someone Did. A Rotation Shows Who They Are.
Succession is usually covered as a governance duty, a risk the board must manage. Target's story is really about something more human: the discipline of seeing people in many different rooms before betting on one of them.
That rotation did more than build experience. It let the board watch how each candidate behaved when the work changed: what they noticed, what they protected, how people responded to them, where they grew. A track record tells you what someone achieved in a familiar setting. A new role tells you who they are when the setting is unfamiliar. That is the information a board needs most, and it can only be gathered over years.
Boards are leaning hard on insiders. According to Russell Reynolds Associates' Global CEO Turnover Index, 88% of incoming S&P 500 CEOs in the first half of 2026 were internal appointments, the highest first-half share in its tracking. That makes the quality of a board's knowledge of its people more important, not less. An insider is only a safe choice if the board truly knows the person and not just the reputation. Familiarity and knowledge are not the same thing.
A strong succession process is a valuable kind of standardization. It starts early, keeps several credible options open, and judges every candidate against the same future needs. Target's version worked because that structure was filled with years of direct observation.
Moving Across the Building
Cornell's move across the building addresses the second place succession often breaks. Many new CEOs inherit the title but not the room. The predecessor stays visible, the team keeps checking in with the old boss, and the successor is quietly expected to be a sequel.
By stepping away, Cornell gave Fiddelke room to lead as himself. He stayed available for advice and met with leaders when needed, but he made clear whose company it was. That takes a leader who is secure in what he built and convinced that his job now is to make someone else successful. It also signals to everyone else in the company that the new leader is not on probation. People take their cues from where the former chief sits, literally and figuratively. Not every founder or long-tenured chief can do it. The ones who can tend to leave organizations that keep improving after they go.
I wrote about the leaders hiding in plain sight inside most companies in Your Next Disrupter May Already Be on Your Payroll. Target's story shows what it takes to find them: deliberate exposure, honest observation and patience.
Questions for Boards and CEOs This Quarter
Can you name your top three internal successors and describe how each one leads in a crisis, not just what each one has delivered?
When did the board last see those candidates in a role outside their expertise? If the answer is never, the board knows their résumés, not them.
Who around each candidate tells you the truth about how they treat people? That perspective rarely shows up in a board deck.
And for sitting CEOs: what will you do on the day your successor is named to make sure there is only one leader in the room?
Leaders who think carefully about what should stay the same and what should change make better successors, a point I explored in What Stays the Same and What Changes Is the First Question a Leader Should Answer. The best predecessors do the same thinking in reverse.
Succession plans fail when boards wait until they need a CEO to start learning who their leaders really are. Target began years earlier, and it showed.
The best way to choose a leader is to have watched who they become when the room keeps changing.
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
The best way to choose a leader is to have watched who they become when the room keeps changing.
© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
This article is the original work of Glenn Llopis and is protected by copyright. It may not be republished, reproduced, distributed or adapted, in whole or in part, in print, online or by AI tools, without prior written consent. You are welcome to share the link or quote a brief excerpt with credit to Glenn Llopis and a link back to this page. For permission requests, contact solutions@glennllopisgroup.com.
Get the next essay in your inbox
New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.
Something went wrong. Please try again.


