Conviction
·
Resilience
Telling Their Story Helps Teens. Just Not the Way We Think.
Young people who found growth in their story of a hard year were doing better a year later. Yet a four-year study found that reflecting on memories did not predict later changes in how students explored or committed to their identities. Here is what that honest mix of findings means for how parents listen.

When something hard happens to our kids, most of us reach for the same advice. Talk about it. Write it down. Get it out. We assume that telling the story is what heals it.
The research on young people's life stories says something more interesting than that. Telling the story does seem to matter. But how a young person tells it, and what they decide it means, matters more than simply telling it. And reflecting on the past, by itself, may not change who they become nearly as much as we hope.
633 Students and the Spring Everything Stopped
In the spring of 2020, college campuses across the country emptied almost overnight. A research team led by Jordan Booker, including Kate McLean of Western Washington University, asked 633 first-year U.S. college students, with an average age just under 19, to write about how the pandemic was affecting them. Then the team followed up a year later.
Students whose stories showed what the researchers called narrative growth, finding some learning or positive change inside the disruption, reported better adjustment and stronger identity development and fewer mental health concerns. Those links showed up at the time and again one year later. Growth in the story also partly explained the connection between how much COVID stress a student faced and how well they were adjusting.
A few cautions belong right next to that finding. These were college students, not high schoolers, and most of the sample were women. The study tracked associations, so it cannot prove that writing a growth story produced better adjustment. Students who were already coping well may simply have told more hopeful stories. Still, the pattern lines up with something most of us have seen: two people go through the same hard season, and the one who can find meaning in it tends to carry it differently.
The Four-Year Study That Found Nothing, and Why It Matters
Now the honest twist. A team led by Kit Turner, with Jennifer Lilgendahl, Moin Syed of the University of Minnesota and McLean as senior author, followed college students for four years across 12 waves of data, starting with 639 students on two campuses and using 251 of them in the main growth analyses. Over those years, students generally explored and committed to their identities in healthy ways. But when students reflected deeply on meaningful memories, that reflection did not predict later changes in how they explored or committed to who they were.
In plain terms, the researchers tested whether thinking hard about your own story is what drives identity forward, and they found no evidence that it does. They reported that result rather than burying it. I respect that, and I think parents should too, because it keeps us from turning storytelling into one more technique we push on our kids.
The Script Is Part of the Story
So how do both findings fit together? McLean, with Monisha Pasupathi and Moin Syed, has argued in a 2023 preprint that the stories we tell about ourselves are shaped by the scripts our culture hands us and by who holds power in the room. Some life stories are easy to tell because everyone already expects them. Others are hard to tell because no one has made space for them.
That helps me make sense of the research. Reflection alone doesn't build an identity. A young person also needs a story they are allowed to tell, and someone willing to hear it without rewriting it.
I wrote about those inherited scripts in Parents Were Handed the Same Script. Teenagers get handed one too. After a disappointment, the script says: shake it off, stay positive, look at the bright side. After a failure, it says: what did you learn? Those aren't bad questions. But when we rush a teen toward the lesson, we often skip the part where they decide for themselves what happened. Then the "growth" in their story is really ours, borrowed and recited. And a borrowed meaning is one more way young people learn to edit themselves for the adults in the room.
How to Listen So the Story Stays Theirs
Ask for the story before the lesson. "What happened?" and "What was that like?" come before "What did you learn?" Sometimes a long time before.
Let them sit in the hard part. Growth that is real usually shows up after the pain has been named, not instead of it. If you jump to the silver lining, a teen hears that the hard part wasn't welcome.
Notice the meaning they reach on their own, and name it back. "It sounds like that game showed you that you're the one people look to when things fall apart." You are not supplying the meaning. You are showing them you heard it.
Don't treat journaling or reflection exercises as a cure. The four-year study is a useful check on that instinct. Reflection is one ingredient. The relationship around it, and the freedom to act on what they discover, matter as much.
Give them room to tell it differently next year. A teen's story about the same event will change as they change. That is not inconsistency. It is development. As I explored in Self-Awareness Is Built in Public, young people come to know themselves in conversation with others, not alone in their heads.
For us as parents, the conviction we are trying to grow in our kids isn't something we can hand them through a lesson. It is earned when they look back at a hard season, decide for themselves what it meant, and then act on that meaning. Our part is to listen long enough for the story to become theirs.
Research cited
Booker, J. A., Ell, M., Fivush, R., et al. (2022). Early impacts of college, interrupted: Considering first-year students' narratives about COVID and reports of adjustment during college shutdowns. Psychological Science.
Turner, K., Lilgendahl, J. P., Syed, M., et al. (2023). Testing exploratory narrative processing as a mechanism of change in identity status processes over 4 years in college-going emerging adults. Developmental Psychology.
McLean, K. C., Pasupathi, M., & Syed, M. (2023). Cognitive scripts and narrative identity are shaped by structures of power. PsyArXiv (preprint).
Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.
A story becomes strength when the person telling it decides what it means, and when someone who loves them is patient enough to let them.
© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
This article is the original work of Glenn Llopis and is protected by copyright. It may not be republished, reproduced, distributed or adapted, in whole or in part, in print, online or by AI tools, without prior written consent. You are welcome to share the link or quote a brief excerpt with credit to Glenn Llopis and a link back to this page. For permission requests, contact solutions@glennllopisgroup.com.
Get the next essay in your inbox
New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.
Something went wrong. Please try again.


