Conviction

·

Resilience

Why Sticking With an Activity Matters More Than We Think

When grades slip, the team or the club is often the first thing parents take away. A study of 545 at-risk Canadian students found that steady involvement in school activities went with lower odds of dropping out, while interrupted involvement looked like none at all. Continuity may be the point.

By Glenn Llopis

·

5

min read

Why Sticking With an Activity Matters More Than We Think, an article by Glenn Llopis

The report card comes home, a grade has slipped, and one of the first things many of us reach for is the activity. No more practice until that grade comes up. No rehearsals until the missing work is in.

I understand the instinct. The activity is the thing our kids care about most, so it feels like the strongest lever we have. Some schools build the same logic into eligibility rules. But a line of research from Quebec suggests we may be pulling the wrong lever, and that the steadiness of a teenager's involvement may matter more than we think.

What 545 Students Showed About Staying Involved

A research team led by Éliane Thouin, with Véronique Dupéré and University of Texas at Austin sociologist Robert Crosnoe among the co-authors, studied 545 high-risk Canadian high school students. These were young people already at elevated risk of leaving school. The researchers looked at whether each student had been involved in school-based activities over the past year, and whether that involvement had been steady or interrupted.

As Thouin and colleagues wrote in Applied Developmental Science, "consistent involvement in the past year was associated with lower odds of dropout." The odds ratio was 0.32, which means the odds of dropping out were roughly a third as high.

The second finding is the one that stopped me. Students whose involvement had been interrupted, through cancellations or exclusions, were about as likely to drop out as students who had never been involved at all. The benefit seemed to depend on the activity lasting. The authors raised the possibility that excluding students from activities, as some academic eligibility rules do, may add to the very risk those rules are meant to address.

I want to be careful here. This was an observational study, not an experiment. Teens who stay involved may differ in ways a survey can't fully capture, and the sample was at-risk students in Canada. It doesn't prove that keeping a teen on the team will keep them in school. It does suggest that continuity deserves more weight than we usually give it.

Some Schools Use Activities to Include

An earlier paper from the same research group, led by Julie McCabe, looked at 12 Quebec high schools that differed in how well their activities helped prevent dropout among vulnerable students. Combining student data with interviews of school staff, the team found a clear contrast. In the more effective schools, activities were used to support engagement and perseverance for all students, including vulnerable ones, and staff had the resources and inclusive practices to make that real. In the less effective schools, activities mostly served to attract well-functioning students from middle-class families, and resources flowed mainly to them.

Similar activities on paper. Very different rooms.

Coming Back Is How a Teen Gets Known

Here is how I read all of this. An activity a teen sticks with isn't just a line on a resume. It is a room where they get to be someone over time. The coach who has watched them for three seasons knows things about them that no report card shows. The teammates who have seen them on bad days and good ones stop seeing a label and start seeing a person.

That kind of knowing takes repetition. A teen who keeps showing up to the same rehearsal hall or the same practice field is quietly collecting evidence about who they are. What they're good at. What they do when it gets hard. What people start coming to them for. Interrupt that, and the evidence stops piling up.

In fairness, nothing in this research says variety is bad. Trying different things, especially early on, is how many young people discover what fits, and the studies didn't compare a sampler with a specialist. The point is narrower and, I think, more useful: once a teen has found a room where they belong, the steadiness of their place in it matters.

This is also where structure and freedom work together. A season, a rehearsal schedule, a coach's expectations: that structure gives a teen something to push against. The freedom is in how they show up inside it. Each room in a young person's life needs its own mix, and an activity is often the room where the mix feels most natural. I made a related case in Room to Roam Is Not Enough. Kids Need Room to Be Themselves.

Before You Take the Team Away

Think twice before using the activity as leverage. If a grade slips, consider keeping the activity and adding support around the schoolwork instead. Rules and consequences still have their place. The question is which consequence protects the thing that's keeping your teen connected.

If your school has eligibility rules, talk with the coach or director early. Many would rather help a student catch up than lose them from the roster.

When your teen wants to quit, ask whether it's the activity or the room. Sometimes the passion has faded. Sometimes a friendship broke or a coach changed. Those call for different answers.

Help them find one place to stay a while. Not five commitments. One room where they keep coming back, long enough to be known.

And ask them, now and then: "What changes when you show up?" Their answer will tell you whether that room is still theirs.

As I wrote in Raise the Individual, Not the Resume, we are not building an application. We are raising a person. A teenager rarely discovers who they are in a single season. They discover it by coming back.

Research cited

Thouin, É., Dupéré, V., Dion, E., et al. (2020). School-based extracurricular activity involvement and high school dropout among at-risk students: Consistency matters. Applied Developmental Science.

McCabe, J., Dupéré, V., Dion, E., et al. (2018). Why do extracurricular activities prevent dropout more effectively in some high schools than in others? A mixed-method examination of organizational dynamics. Applied Developmental Science.

Want to explore these ideas further? Learn more about my work on leadership, identity and conviction at www.theglennllopis.com.

Conviction Wisdom

A teenager rarely discovers who they are in a single season; they discover it by coming back.

Glenn Llopis

Founder and CEO of Glenn Llopis Group, author of six books and creator of Leadership in the Age of Personalization.

Take the Conviction Diagnostic
SUBSCRIBE

Get the next essay in your inbox

New essays on leadership, identity and conviction, sent to you when they publish. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Thank you. You're subscribed to Conviction Chronicles.

Something went wrong. Please try again.

The Conviction Diagnostic
How much of you is edited?

Take the Conviction Diagnostic. In three minutes, see where you've traded who you are for who the room wanted, and exactly where to begin reclaiming it.

Start with the question most leaders can’t answer in a sentence: What do you solve for?
Begin the Conviction Diagnostic

© 2026 Glenn Llopis Group, LLC · All Rights Reserved

Identity Catalyst · ˈyō-pēs